Different Dog vs butternut box: Which is Better for your dog

Spread the love

As a dog owner, you want to provide your furry companion with the best possible nutrition to keep them healthy and happy. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right dog food delivery service.

Two popular options in the UK are Butternut Box and Different Dog. Both brands offer high-quality, nutritious meals made with fresh ingredients and delivered straight to your door. But which one is the best choice for your four-legged friend?

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the similarities and differences between Butternut Box and Different Dog, so you can make an informed decision on which dog food delivery service to choose.

Why Fresh Dog Food for Dogs?

Dogs are more than just pets; they are a part of our family. As responsible pet owners, it is our duty to ensure that our furry friends receive the best possible care, including their diet.

Feeding your dog with fresh, high-quality food is essential for their health and well-being. In this section, we will discuss why fresh dog food is important for dogs.

Improved Digestion

Fresh dog food contains natural ingredients that are easy to digest, making it ideal for dogs with digestive issues. The ingredients used in fresh dog food are minimally processed, ensuring that the essential nutrients are not lost during the cooking process.

This makes it easier for your dog’s digestive system to absorb the nutrients, resulting in better overall health.

Better Nutrition

Fresh dog food is made with natural, high-quality ingredients, providing your dog with all the essential nutrients they need.

Unlike traditional dog food, which may contain fillers and preservatives, fresh dog food is made with real meat, vegetables, and fruits, providing a well-balanced diet that meets your dog’s nutritional needs.

Improved Health

Feeding your dog with fresh, high-quality food can improve their overall health. Fresh dog food is made with natural ingredients, providing your dog with essential nutrients that boost their immune system, improve their coat and skin health, and promote healthy digestion.

Additionally, fresh dog food may help reduce the risk of obesity, diabetes, and other health issues that are common in dogs fed on commercial dog food.

Increased Energy

Feeding your dog with fresh, high-quality food can increase their energy levels, making them more active and playful.

The natural ingredients used in fresh dog food provide your dog with essential nutrients that promote healthy muscle development and support overall health, leading to increased energy and vitality.

Better Tasting

Fresh dog food tastes better than commercial dog food, making it more appealing to your dog. The natural ingredients used in fresh dog food provide a rich, flavorful taste that dogs love, making mealtime more enjoyable for them.

Feeding your dog with fresh, high-quality food is essential for their health and well-being. Fresh dog food provides improved digestion, better nutrition, improved health, increased energy, and better taste, making it an excellent choice for pet owners who want to provide the best possible care for their furry friends.

If you’re looking for a convenient way to feed your dog with fresh, customized meals, consider using a dog food delivery service like Butternut Box or Different Dog.

What Is Butternut Box?

Butternut Box is a UK-based dog food delivery service that offers fresh, customized meals for dogs. The company was founded in 2016 by two friends, Kevin Glynn and David Nolan, who were disappointed with the low-quality ingredients used in commercial dog food.

The founders of Butternut Box set out to create a fresh dog food delivery service that would provide dogs with the nutrition they need to live healthy, happy lives. They developed their own recipes, using high-quality, natural ingredients, and began delivering fresh meals to dog owners across the UK.

Butternut Box meals are made using 60% meat, and the remaining 40% is a mix of vegetables, fruits, and other natural ingredients. The company uses only human-grade ingredients, ensuring that your dog receives the same quality of food that you do.

One of the key features of Butternut Box is the customization of their meals. When you sign up, you will be asked a series of questions about your dog’s breed, weight, age, and any dietary restrictions or health issues they may have.

Based on this information, Butternut Box will create a customized meal plan for your dog, ensuring that they receive the proper nutrition they need to stay healthy.

Butternut Box offers four different meal plans based on your dog’s needs. The “Naked” plan is a simple, single protein meal made with chicken, turkey, beef, or fish. The “Classic” plan offers a variety of meat options, as well as vegetables and fruits. The “Low Fat” plan is ideal for dogs with weight issues, and the “Grain Free” plan is perfect for dogs with food sensitivities.

All of Butternut Box’s meals are free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors, ensuring that your dog receives only the best, natural ingredients. The company also offers a 14-day trial, allowing you to try their meals before committing to a subscription.

Butternut Box meals are delivered directly to your door, and the company uses eco-friendly packaging to reduce their environmental impact. The meals are packaged in individual portions, making it easy to store and serve. All you need to do is defrost the meal and serve it to your dog.

In addition to their meal delivery service, Butternut Box also offers a range of dog treats, including their popular “Woofin” muffins. These muffins are made with the same high-quality, natural ingredients as their meals, making them a healthy and delicious treat for your dog.

Overall, Butternut Box is an excellent choice for pet owners who want to provide their dogs with fresh, customized meals made with high-quality, natural ingredients. The company’s commitment to sustainability, customization, and quality make it one of the best dog food delivery services available in the UK.

What Is a Different Dog?

Different Dog is a UK-based dog food delivery service that offers fresh, human-grade meals for dogs. The company was founded in 2017 by Alex and Charlie, two dog owners who were dissatisfied with the low-quality ingredients and lack of transparency in the pet food industry.

Different Dog’s meals are made with 100% natural, human-grade ingredients, and are free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. The company sources its ingredients from UK farms and producers, ensuring that they are of the highest quality.

One of the key features of Different Dog is the variety of meals they offer. The company offers a rotating menu of different recipes, ensuring that your dog never gets bored with their food. Different Dog meals are available in four different sizes, making it easy to find the right portion size for your dog.

When you sign up for Different Dog, you will be asked a series of questions about your dog’s breed, weight, age, and any dietary restrictions or health issues they may have.

Based on this information, Different Dog will create a customized meal plan for your dog, ensuring that they receive the proper nutrition they need to stay healthy.

Different Dog offers a range of different meal plans, including their “Everyday” plan, which offers a variety of different recipes, and their “Single Protein” plan, which is ideal for dogs with food sensitivities. The company also offers a range of treats, including their popular “Liver Brownies,” which are made with fresh chicken liver and other natural ingredients.

Different Dog meals are delivered directly to your door, and the company uses eco-friendly packaging to reduce their environmental impact. The meals are packaged in individual portions, making it easy to store and serve. All you need to do is defrost the meal and serve it to your dog.

Overall, Different Dog is an excellent choice for pet owners who want to provide their dogs with fresh, customized meals made with high-quality, natural ingredients. The company’s commitment to transparency, variety, and quality make it one of the best dog food delivery services available in the UK.

Butternut Box Review

Butternut Box is a UK-based dog food delivery service that offers fresh, human-grade meals for dogs. The company was founded in 2016 by two dog owners who were unhappy with the quality of commercial dog food on the market.

Butternut Box meals are made with 60% meat, 40% vegetables and fruit, and a unique blend of vitamins and minerals to ensure that your dog receives a balanced diet.

All ingredients are sourced from the UK and Europe, and the company works closely with vets and nutritionists to ensure that their meals meet the highest standards of quality and nutrition.

One of the key features of Butternut Box is the variety of meals they offer. The company offers four different recipes, each made with a different type of meat, including beef, chicken, lamb, and turkey.

Butternut Box also offers a range of treats, including their popular “Cheesy Chews,” which are made with natural ingredients and are ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs.

When you sign up for Butternut Box, you will be asked a series of questions about your dog’s breed, weight, age, and any dietary restrictions or health issues they may have. Based on this information, Butternut Box will create a customized meal plan for your dog, ensuring that they receive the proper nutrition they need to stay healthy.

Overall, Butternut Box is an excellent choice for pet owners who want to provide their dogs with fresh, high-quality meals made with natural ingredients. The company’s commitment to quality, nutrition, and variety make it one of the best dog food delivery services available in the UK.

Different Dog Review

Different Dog is a UK-based dog food delivery service that offers fresh, human-grade meals for dogs. The company prides itself on using only 100% natural ingredients, free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors.

Different Dog was founded in 2017 by two dog owners who were frustrated with the low-quality ingredients and lack of transparency in the pet food industry.

Different Dog meals are made with a combination of fresh meat, vegetables, and fruit, all sourced from UK farms and producers. The company works closely with vets and nutritionists to ensure that their meals are nutritionally balanced and provide all the nutrients that dogs need to stay healthy.

When you sign up for Different Dog, you will be asked a series of questions about your dog’s breed, weight, age, and any dietary restrictions or health issues they may have.

Based on this information, Different Dog will create a customized meal plan for your dog, ensuring that they receive the proper nutrition they need to stay healthy.

The company also offers a range of treats, including their popular “Liver Brownies,” which are made with fresh chicken liver and other natural ingredients.

Overall, Different Dog is an excellent choice for pet owners who want to provide their dogs with fresh, high-quality meals made with natural ingredients. The company’s commitment to quality, variety, and nutrition make it one of the best dog food delivery services available in the UK.

Quality of Ingredients

The quality of ingredients used in dog food is a crucial factor in determining its overall nutritional value and health benefits for our furry companions. When looking for a dog food delivery service, it’s important to consider the quality of ingredients used in their recipes.

Both Butternut Box and Different Dog pride themselves on using high-quality, natural ingredients in their meals.

Butternut Box uses a combination of 60% meat and 40% vegetables and fruit, all sourced from the UK and Europe. They believe that fresh, whole ingredients are key to providing dogs with the essential nutrients they need to thrive.

Different Dog takes a slightly different approach, using 100% natural ingredients, all sourced from UK farms and producers. They believe in using only whole, single-source proteins in their recipes, such as chicken, beef, and fish, to provide dogs with a balanced and complete diet.

In terms of the specific ingredients used, both companies offer a wide range of recipes to choose from, catering to dogs with different dietary requirements and preferences. For example, Butternut Box offers recipes that are grain-free, hypoallergenic, and low-fat, while Different Dog offers a range of recipes that are tailored to dogs of different ages and activity levels.

Ultimately, the quality of ingredients used in a dog food delivery service is essential to ensuring that your dog is getting the nutrition they need to live a healthy and happy life. By choosing a service that uses high-quality, natural ingredients, you can be confident that you’re providing your furry friend with the best possible diet.

Price

When it comes to choosing a dog food delivery service, price is an important consideration for many pet owners. Both Butternut Box and Different Dog offer high-quality, fresh meals made with natural ingredients, but there are differences in their pricing structures.

Butternut Box offers a range of meal plans starting at £1.31 per day for a small dog, with prices increasing for larger dogs and longer meal plans. Their meal plans include a variety of recipes, with options for grain-free, hypoallergenic, and low-fat diets. They also offer customized meal plans to meet your dog’s specific dietary requirements.

Different Dog’s meal plans start at £1.40 per day for a small dog, with prices increasing for larger dogs and longer meal plans. They offer a range of recipes that are tailored to dogs of different ages and activity levels, and all of their meals are made with 100% natural ingredients sourced from UK farms and producers.

While Butternut Box is slightly cheaper than Different Dog, the difference in price is minimal. It’s worth noting that both services offer high-quality, fresh meals made with natural ingredients, which may cost more than traditional kibble or canned dog food.

However, many pet owners believe that the health benefits of feeding their dogs fresh, natural meals outweigh the higher cost.

Ultimately, the cost of a dog food delivery service will depend on your budget and your dog’s specific dietary needs. It’s important to compare prices and meal plans carefully to ensure that you’re getting the best value for your money while still providing your furry friend with a healthy and balanced diet.

Delivery and Packaging

Delivery and packaging are important factors to consider when choosing a dog food delivery service. Both Butternut Box and Different Dog take great care in ensuring that their meals are delivered fresh and in a way that minimizes waste.

Butternut Box delivers their meals in boxes that are insulated with recycled denim and wool, which helps to keep the meals cool during transit.

The boxes are also recyclable and biodegradable, which helps to reduce the environmental impact of their packaging. Butternut Box offers free delivery to most parts of the UK, and their meals are delivered on a regular basis, depending on the meal plan you choose.

Different Dog delivers their meals in eco-friendly, insulated boxes made from recycled paper and card, which are fully recyclable and biodegradable. Their meals are delivered frozen to ensure maximum freshness and can be stored in the freezer until you’re ready to feed them to your dog.

Different Dog offers free delivery to most parts of the UK, and their meals are delivered on a regular basis, depending on the meal plan you choose.

Both companies offer convenient and reliable delivery options, with meals arriving at your doorstep on a regular basis. The insulated packaging used by both companies helps to keep the meals fresh and cool during transit, ensuring that they arrive in optimal condition. The eco-friendly packaging used by both companies also helps to minimize waste and reduce the environmental impact of their services.

When choosing a dog food delivery service, it’s important to consider the delivery and packaging options available, as these can have an impact on the quality and freshness of the meals you receive, as well as their environmental impact.

Both Butternut Box and Different Dog take great care in ensuring that their meals are delivered in a way that is both convenient for pet owners and sustainable for the environment.

Customer Service

Customer service is an important factor to consider when choosing a dog food delivery service. Both Butternut Box and Different Dog are known for their excellent customer service, which includes responsive support, easy ordering, and flexible cancellation policies.

Butternut Box offers a variety of ways to contact their customer support team, including email, phone, and live chat. Their team is known for being responsive and helpful, and they are available to answer any questions or concerns that customers may have.

Butternut Box also offers a flexible subscription model, which allows customers to pause or cancel their subscription at any time, making it easy to manage their meal plan.

Different Dog also offers a variety of ways to contact their customer support team, including email, phone, and live chat. Their team is known for being responsive and helpful, and they are available to answer any questions or concerns that customers may have.

Different Dog also offers a flexible subscription model, which allows customers to pause or cancel their subscription at any time.

Both companies offer easy-to-use websites and ordering systems, making it simple to manage your meal plan and make changes as needed. They also offer a variety of payment options, including credit card and PayPal, to make ordering and payment as convenient as possible.

When choosing a dog food delivery service, it’s important to consider the level of customer service offered, as this can have a big impact on your overall experience. Both Butternut Box and Different Dog are known for their responsive and helpful customer support teams, making it easy to manage your meal plan and get the help you need if you have any questions or concerns.

Their flexible subscription models also make it easy to manage your subscription and make changes as needed.

Sustainability and Ethics

Sustainability and ethics are important considerations when choosing a dog food delivery service. Both Butternut Box and Different Dog prioritize sustainability and ethical sourcing when it comes to the ingredients they use in their meals.

Butternut Box sources their ingredients from ethical and sustainable suppliers, and they use only human-grade meat, which means that their meals are made from the same quality ingredients that you would find in your own meals.

They also use seasonal ingredients whenever possible, which helps to minimize their environmental impact and support local farmers. Butternut Box’s packaging is also eco-friendly, with their boxes made from recycled materials and insulation made from recycled denim and wool.

Different Dog also sources their ingredients from ethical and sustainable suppliers, and they use only high-quality ingredients in their meals.

They prioritize using organic ingredients and free-range meat, and they avoid using any artificial preservatives or additives in their meals. Different Dog’s packaging is also eco-friendly, with their boxes made from recycled paper and card and insulation made from recycled materials.

Both companies are committed to sustainability and ethical sourcing, and they take great care in ensuring that their meals are made from high-quality ingredients that are sourced in a responsible and sustainable way. By using eco-friendly packaging and supporting ethical suppliers, they are also reducing their environmental impact and promoting sustainable practices in the pet food industry.

When choosing a dog food delivery service, it’s important to consider the sustainability and ethics of the ingredients used in the meals, as well as the environmental impact of the packaging used.

Both Butternut Box and Different Dog are committed to using sustainable and ethical ingredients, and they use eco-friendly packaging to minimize waste and reduce their environmental impact.

Positives and Negative of Butternut Box

Positives of Butternut Box:

Negatives of Butternut Box to consider:

Overall, Butternut Box is a great option for dog owners who are looking for high-quality, personalized meals for their dogs.

While it may be more expensive than traditional dog food and has some limitations, the quality of the ingredients and the convenience of the service make it a popular choice among dog owners.

Positives and Negative of Different Dog

Positives of Different Dog:

Negatives of Different Dog to consider:

Overall, Different Dog is a great option for dog owners who are looking for high-quality, personalized meals for their dogs.

While it may be more expensive than traditional dog food and has some limitations, the quality of the ingredients and the wide selection of meals make it a popular choice among dog owners.

Personal Experience with Butternut Box

When we first transitioned from feeding kibble to fresh dog meals, we decided to go with Butternut Box. Back then, they only had four recipes available, which seemed like a decent selection at the time.

Our dogs, Michael and Tony, enjoyed all four recipes and we appreciated being able to rotate their meals to keep them interested in their food.

However, now that Butternut Box offers ten different recipes, our dogs are absolutely spoiled for choice. Their favorites include Pork This Way, Wham Bam Lamb, and You’ve Got Game.

One of the things that really impressed us with Butternut Box is that our normally picky eaters didn’t get bored of their meals. They licked their bowls clean every time, which was a great sight to see.

While the meals do take up some freezer space, we found that we could adjust our delivery frequency to every two or four weeks to suit our needs. Opting for fewer deliveries also resulted in a cheaper overall price. We ultimately settled on a monthly delivery schedule, which has worked out well for us.

Out of all the dog food delivery companies we’ve tried, we believe that Butternut Box offers the best overall value for the quality of the food and the price. Our dogs have never been healthier and they continue to devour their meals without hesitation.

Personal Experience with Different Dog

After a brief hiatus from Butternut Box towards the end of 2022, we decided to give Different Dog a try due to a delay in one of our boxes from Butternut Box. We were immediately impressed with the quality of Different Dog’s meals, which looked and tasted like real food.

Michael, our dog, was just as enthusiastic about his Different Dog meals as he was about his Butternut Box meals, evidenced by his wagging tail. However, Tony, who is pickier, wasn’t as excited during mealtime and preferred Butternut Box.

While Different Dog’s meals are undoubtedly of excellent quality, we did face some challenges in storing them in our freezer. The meals were an awkward shape that required us to purchase a small freezer specifically for our dog food.

Additionally, we noticed that the boxes stained easily when defrosted, although they were more environmentally friendly than Butternut Box’s plastic packaging.

One area where Different Dog excels is in their vast range of recipes, which currently stands at twelve, two more than Butternut Box.

Overall, Different Dog provided us with an excellent alternative to Butternut Box during our break from their service. However, while we appreciated the quality of Different Dog’s meals and the environmentally friendly packaging, we found Butternut Box to be more convenient to store and transport due to their freezer-friendly packaging.

Butternut Box Vs Different Dog: Our Pick

After trying both Butternut Box and Different Dog, I recommend Butternut Box as my top pick. Here’s why:

First and foremost, the taste test was won by Butternut Box. While Michael enjoyed both brands, Tony can be picky when it comes to dog food. But she has never refused any Butternut Box meals, regardless of the recipe, whereas she turned her nose up at some of Different Dog’s meals.

Secondly, I found it easier to store Butternut Box than Different Dog. Butternut Box meals are frozen in plastic packaging that can be stored on one of your freezer shelves, whereas Different Dog’s rectangular cardboard packaging was more difficult to store. I even had to invest in a second freezer to fit all their meals, and that was only two weeks’ worth of food.

Lastly, Butternut Box represents better overall value. Although Different Dog offers premium dog food, it comes at a premium price. While they have worked to bring down the cost over the years, it’s still significantly more expensive than Butternut Box.

If you’re feeding multiple dogs or have a large breed, you may feel a significant strain on your budget. Butternut Box is still more expensive than your average dog food brand from a local supermarket, but it’s a more affordable price for the quality of food and service provided.

Key factors to keep in mind while selecting a dog food delivery service

When selecting a dog food delivery service, there are several key factors to keep in mind.

Firstly, consider the quality of ingredients. Look for companies that use fresh, whole food ingredients without any artificial additives or fillers. You want to make sure that your dog is getting a nutritionally balanced diet that is both healthy and tasty.

Secondly, think about the price. While high-quality dog food can be more expensive than standard kibble, you don’t want to break the bank. Look for delivery services that offer competitive pricing for the quality of food they provide.

Thirdly, consider the delivery and packaging. Make sure that the food will be delivered to your doorstep in a timely manner and that the packaging will keep the food fresh and safe.

Fourthly, customer service is an important factor to consider. Look for delivery services that have a helpful and responsive customer service team in case you have any issues or concerns.

Lastly, sustainability and ethics are increasingly important factors to consider. Look for companies that use sustainable and ethical practices in sourcing their ingredients and packaging their products.

Conclusion

After a thorough comparison between Butternut Box and Different Dog, it is clear that both companies offer high-quality, nutritious dog food that can provide your furry friend with a well-balanced diet. However, when it comes to choosing the best dog food delivery service, it is essential to consider a few key factors.

In terms of recipe options, Butternut Box offers 10 different customized recipes to cater to your dog’s specific dietary needs, while Different Dog offers a peerless range of recipes that exceed Butternut Box by two more. Both companies use fresh, high-quality ingredients, and the meals are handmade in the UK.

However, when it comes to taste preference, Butternut Box emerged as the winner, with a 4.9-star rating based on over 15,000 reviews on Trustpilot. Tony, a picky eater, showed a clear preference for Butternut Box meals, while Michael was equally happy with both brands.

Storage is another important factor to consider. Butternut Box meals can be stored easily in the freezer and defrosted when needed, whereas Different Dog’s meals come in a slightly awkward shape that requires extra freezer space and cardboard packaging that may become stained after defrosting.

Lastly, Butternut Box offers better overall value compared to Different Dog. While Different Dog offers premium dog food, it is at a more premium price, which may not be ideal for those with multiple dogs or large breeds. Butternut Box is more affordable than Different Dog, making it a better option for budget-conscious dog owners.

while both Butternut Box and Different Dog offer quality dog food, Butternut Box stands out as the better option. Their customized recipe options, ease of storage, and excellent reputation among picky eaters make it the ideal choice for pet owners who want to provide their furry friends with healthy and delicious meals.

FAQs Related to Butternut Box vs Different Dog

What are Butternut Box and Different Dog?

Butternut Box and Different Dog are dog food delivery companies that specialize in providing fresh, high-quality meals for dogs.

How are Butternut Box and Different Dog different from regular dog food?

Butternut Box and Different Dog use fresh ingredients to create meals that are tailored to meet the specific nutritional needs of dogs. Regular dog food, on the other hand, is often heavily processed and may contain preservatives and fillers.

Are Butternut Box and Different Dog expensive?

Both Butternut Box and Different Dog are more expensive than regular dog food, but the quality of the ingredients and the personalized nature of the meals justify the higher cost.

Are Butternut Box and Different Dog suitable for all dogs?

Butternut Box and Different Dog offer a range of recipes that are designed to meet the needs of dogs of all ages, breeds, and sizes. However, it’s always a good idea to consult with a veterinarian before making any major changes to your dog’s diet.

Can I customize my dog’s meals with Butternut Box and Different Dog?

Both companies offer the option to customize your dog’s meals based on their specific dietary requirements and preferences.

Are Butternut Box and Different Dog environmentally friendly?

Both companies strive to minimize their environmental impact by using recyclable and biodegradable packaging materials.

Which company is better – Butternut Box or Different Dog?

The choice between Butternut Box and Different Dog ultimately depends on your individual preferences and your dog’s specific needs. It’s recommended to try both companies and determine which one works best for you and your furry friend

Different Dog vs butternut box: Which is Better for your dog